
Short answer Historical ice cream molds made shapes such as asparagus and fish. This is a story about vegetable shapes, not confirmed vegetable flavors.
Asparagus on the dessert plate? Historical ice creams could pull off that disguise.
Cook Agnes Marshall described and sold dessert molds shaped like asparagus, fish and swans.
I was already bracing myself for vegetables.

Ice cream was packed into molds to give it shape. The photo shows several designs from Marshall's book.
History museums recreate these desserts, too. Briefly dipping the mold in warm water helps release the ice cream.
Asparagus-shaped isn't the same as asparagus-flavored. What the records confirm here is the mold and its shape.
Even ice cream gets a vegetable costume.
Watch it as a short
Sources
Photo credits
- Fancy Ices ice cream illustration.jpg, Agnes B. Marshall, Public domain (source)
- The Book of Ices: asparagus mould, printed page 56 (JPEG conversion), Agnes B. Marshall / University of Leeds Library, Public domain (source)
More useless facts
FoodBananas Are BerriesStrawberries aren't berries, but bananas are
FoodKetchup Used to Be Fish SauceThe word ketchup came from a name for pickled fish brine
FoodThe BBC Once Said Spaghetti Grows on TreesOn April Fools' Day 1957, hundreds of Britons called to ask how to grow a spaghetti tree
SportsBumpy ice helps these stones slideBefore curling games, droplets are sprayed onto the rink to form tiny ice bumps